I honestly don't know anyone who could say they saw
this coming. The United States Olympic team lost 3-1 in the Gold Medal game against Japan, a team they had beat in extra innings earlier.
Everyone is going to look for someone to blame here. That's natural. The U.S. was expected to win, they expected to win, and now someone or something is going to be blamed.
It's hard to blame the actual game play. Some days you just aren't going to hit, pitch or play defense well. Some days, unfortunately, these run together. It's a part of the game. However, there are
controllables, and one of those things is the game-time decisions made by head coach Mike Candrea.
First, as a disclaimer, I think Candrea is a fine coach. I honestly haven't seen enough of his in-game decisions to make an educated, all encompassing judgment of him as a coach. As a recruiter at Arizona, he's golden. He built a winner, and now Arizona's recruiting takes care of itself. On Team USA, he manages a Dream Team. It's hard to judge in-game decisions when your players are the best of the best.
That being said, I didn't agree with his decision in the 6th inning. With the United States trailing Japan 2-1, Caitlin Lowe led off the inning with a single. Then, Candrea decided to bunt Mendoza. Ordinarily, trailing by a run in the late innings, that doesn't sound like a terrible move. However, with Crystal Bustos standing on deck, you knew what would happen next. After Mendoza layed down her bunt and was thrown out at first, Lowe moved to second and Bustos came to the plate. Predictably, and wisely, Japan issued an intentional walk to Bustos.
By bunting, Candrea effectively removed the bat from his best hitter. His most feared hitter. She hit a solo home run earlier in the game to give the United States their only run of the game. Ueno had shut down the U.S. lineup, and now, the only player which had gotten to her was being walked. To Kelly Kretschman's credit, she drew a walk to load the bases with one out. After that however, Duran popped to short, and Nuveman popped to second. Furthermore, I question why Nuveman was in the 7th spot in the order to begin with. She is probably the weakest hitter on the team at this point.
Does letting Mendoza swing away automatically change the outcome? Of course not. It does let your players do what they've been taught to do. Hit the ball, and win games. Often times, a coach can be his teams own worst enemy. This can most often happen when a coach is making the status-quo "smart move." It sounds smart on its face, and few will question it, but was it
really the best decision? I don't think so. You
knew by bunting Mendoza, they would intentionally walk Bustos. There was no question about that. For that reason, I wouldn't have bunted. Sometimes, by staying out of your player's ways, you let them win games. This may have been one of those instances.
It's sad that Team USA had to go out on a losing note. Softball will not be played in the 2012 London Olympics.
By the way, Kelly Kretschman, the former Bama great, was one of five U.S. players to lay her cleats on home plate after the game, the traditional signal of retiring from international play. Kretschman was quite the ambassador for Alabama softball, and her retiring marks a somber day for Bama fans. If I find a picture of this, I'll post it.
By the way, I don't think the U.S. losing this game will give the International Olympic Committee any more incentive to put softball back in the Olympics. One great team, and one good team does not equal a competitive and elite level of softball. It's a start, but you need more than two good teams on the international level to warrant a spot in the Olympics.
EDIT: It's been pointed out to me that Mendoza may have bunted on her own. That's entirely possible. If that's the case, my criticism of Candrea is minimized, but not entirely gone. Mendoza needs to know (if she made the decision on her own), what the bunt is doing. It's not only giving up an out, it's taking the bat out of the hands of your team's best hitter. If she doesn't know that, Candrea should let her know that.
Finally, to be very clear, Candrea was in a position I don't envy. Lose, and the whole world looks at every move you made. Win, and I don't blink. I'll admit that. I do believe it's a decision that could have been a bit better, however.
Finally, here are two pictures of Krestchman placing her cleats at home plate to retire from international play as I promised.
